COVID, Cameras + Data Collection: Tracking the tech that tracks us

COVID, Cameras + Data Collection: Tracking the tech that tracks us

A look at the various tech solutions that governments and organizations around the world have adopted to help slow the spread of COVID-19.
Abstract illustration of people with masks connected by their location and phones.
Darren Elias
Communications Intern
​Sarah Villeneuve
Policy Analyst
July 22, 2020
Print Page

This scan was first published on July 22, 2020 and will be updated on an ongoing basis. Most recent update: August 6, 2020.

 

Governments around the world have turned to data-driven technology in an effort to slow the spread of COVID-19. The most prominently discussed technology so far has been contact tracing applications, but these apps are just the tip of the iceberg of pandemic-related technology.

Wearables, from smart rings to anklets, are being developed and adopted across the globe, alongside computer vision software with the ability to measure the distance between individuals in public spaces. While we have seen an accelerated uptake in technological solutions, some of these tools are enterprise-driven or experimental and have not yet been integrated into policy and practice. These technologies have the potential to be used in a variety of combinations and with varying efficacy across jurisdictions. 

However, the increased use of data-driven technologies and heightened surveillance during the pandemic period has led to significant discussion surrounding the trade-off between public health tracking and an individual’s privacy rights. This scan aims to provide an overview of how technology and data is currently being deployed to mitigate the spread of COVID-19, both within Canada and around the world. In doing so, we hope to provide policymakers with a resource outlining how technology is being used in various jurisdictions and contexts. This scan will provide a starting point for discussions and analysis related to existing or required changes in privacy and data policy and legislation. 

Contact Tracing and Exposure Notification Apps

Contract tracing applications are perhaps the most prominent tool being used to combat the spread of COVID-19. Contact tracing is a process that works by identifying and informing individuals who have come into close contact with someone who has tested positive for the disease. Contact tracing has been used by public health authorities in past outbreaks such as SARS and the avian influenza. This process has historically been done manually and there are a few early examples of digitally enabled contact tracing. These early examples include the use of Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) to aid contact tracing during the SARS outbreak. However, mobile contact tracing using smart-phones is a novel and untested approach. A few resources on contact tracing apps have emerged, such as the MIT Technology Review Covid Tracing Tracker and Ryerson’s CyberSecurity Policy Exchange Race to Trace report. Below we provide a brief overview of some recent developments:

  • Australia: COVIDSafe App relies on Bluetooth to recognize other nearby devices that have also downloaded the app. When two phones come in close proximity to one another, the app notes the date, time, distance, and duration of the contact and the other user’s reference code. This information is stored securely on the users phone, and deleted on a 21-day rolling cycle. Prior to the release of the app, parliament passed the Privacy Amendment (Public Health Contact Information) Act to support the COVIDSafe app and ensure users’ privacy is protected.
  • Canada: The federal government launched a COVID Alert exposure notification app in early August. While available for download country-wide, it is only currently active in Ontario. The app uses Bluetooth to identify phones in close proximity to one another for an extended period of time. When two phones meet the time and proximity thresholds, the app generates and shares an anonymous unique identification code which is then stored on both phones for a 14-day period. If a user tests positive with COVID-19, public health officials will help to upload the information to the app. The app will then notify any phones that have a shared identification code.
    • Quebec: In early July, the province launched online consultations to gauge public interest in a contact tracing app
  • Cyprus: One of the earliest contract tracing apps to launch in February, CovTracer is a GPS-based contract tracing app that records the user’s location history. Once a user records they have tested positive in the app, they can choose to become anonymous while still sharing the geo-locations of their past movements on the database. All information is stored on the user’s phone and is deleted when the app is uninstalled. 
  • Germany: Like many other Bluetooth-enabled apps, Germany’s CoronaWarning app identifies other users in close proximity and shares a unique identifier. Data is stored on the individual’s device and deleted after a two-week period. When individuals test positive for COVID-19, they will receive an individualized QR code to scan, which will then signal the app to transmit notifications to those who have come into close contact. To build trust in the app, the developers released the source code prior to its launch. 
  • France: On June 2, 2020, the country’s StopCovid app was made available for download on Apple and Android devices. Since June 23, the app has been downloaded by 1.9 million people, but only 68 users have reported testing positive for COVID-19 in the app. The app doesn’t require you to register your name or address. Users can disable the app and delete their data by uninstalling the app. 
  • Iceland:  Launched in April, Rakning-C app logs the user’s location data and compares it against the movements of others when infection is reported. Unless released to authorities for tracing purposes, the data collected is stored only on the user’s device. It’s been reported that 40 percent of Iceland’s population has used the app.
  • Singapore: The country’s Trace Together app, launched in June, was the first Bluetooth-enabled contract tracing app. All data is stored locally on the users device and is deleted after 21 days. 
  • United Arab Emirates: Like many other Bluetooth-enabled applications, the country’s Trace Covid app will exchange and store secure tracing identifiers on phones that come into close proximity to one another. Individuals can be fined up to AED 10,000 ($3,700) for not downloading the COVID-19 tracing app after being infected with the coronavirus.

Physical Distancing Tools

While contract tracing tools have been widely adopted by various governments around the world, physical distancing tools have only been used by a handful of public authorities. These tools are also being developed and used by private companies to assist with physical distancing among workers as employers reopen. 

  • Australia: A social distancing squad will use 11,000 cameras to monitor physical distancing in Sydney’s busiest transit hubs.
  • Belgium: The port of Antwerp—a key economic hub—is using wristbands to enforce social distancing rules on the workfloor, requiring a specific minimum distance between any two workers. The wearables, supplied by the Dutch company Rombit, use Bluetooth and ultra-wideband technology to give off warning signals when workers come within a specified distance of each other. 
  • Canada: Start-up iMerciv has launched a beta version of its pedestrian navigation app, MapinHood, for use in Toronto. MapinHood’s social distancing mode draws on historic pedestrian foot traffic data to advise users on which streets to use and avoid in order to navigate busy areas and maintain physical distancing. The app also warns of COVID-related risks and has a built-in voluntary survey tools to track local infections.
  • China: The country uses AI-powered surveillance cameras, drone-borne cameras, and portable digital recorders to monitor and restrict the gathering of people in public.
  • Oman: The Royal Oman Police uses drones to spread messages telling people to avoid public spaces and gatherings—and to stay home.
  • Singapore: The government’s National Parks Board uses a fleet of 30 drones to monitor parks and beaches, measuring how crowded certain locations are, and aggregating the data on a website. Additionally, robotic dogs equipped with cameras, remote control, 3D-mapping, and semi-autonomous operations have been deployed to bark orders to park-goers to maintain distancing measures.
  • USA
    • The New Albany, Ohio school district plans to implement a system that would require each student to wear an electronic beacon to track their location to within a few feet, logging which students and teachers are in each classroom throughout the day.
    • Amazon recently deployed clear plastic-sleeve shaped gadgets that give off warning signals when workers violate the distancing mandate at fulfilment centres.
    • Silicon Valley’s Landing AI has developed a new software that can be integrated with existing on-site CCTV to flag groups that are closer than the minimum physical distancing requirements.

Share

Health Monitoring and Symptom Surveillance

The use of technology that helps to monitor the health of a population and detect infections early appears to be growing in use across the globe. This includes a wide range of tools from thermal imaging to AI-driven wearables. 

  • Canada: Sudbury-based company Flosonics Medical has developed a wearable, wireless, single-use monitor that allows clinicians to access critical COVID-19 patient information, including cardiovascular state, remotely through Bluetooth.
  • China
    • A quick response (QR) code system is used by authorities to monitor health and control movement. The QR code serves as a COVID-19 health status certificate and travel pass with colour codes corresponding to risk levels of individuals (assessed based on an individual’s symptom survey responses and temperature recordings).
    • Smart helmets fitted with AI-powered infrared cameras allow Chinese police to identify pedestrians with fever-level temperatures.
    • Authorities in the eastern city of Hangzhou have proposed combining medical records, physical exam results, and data on lifestyle choices to create a healthcare score for citizens. Each of the city’s 10 million residents would be given a colored health badge based on a collation of this data and a score from 1–100 that will be used to create health rankings.
    • The Shanghai Public Health Clinic has used US-based company VivaLNK’s continuous temperature sensors to tackle the spread of coronavirus in China.
  • Germany: The national Robert Koch Institute launched a smartwatch app called the Corona-Datenspende to help monitor the spread of COVID-19 by collecting vitals and analyzing whether current measures are effectively containing the pandemic.
  • Iceland: The government uses mobile technology to collect data on patient-reported symptoms. This data is then combined with clinical and genomic sequencing datasets to reveal key information about the pathology and spread of the coronavirus.
  • Singapore: People have their temperature measured at the entries of workplaces, schools, and public transport. This temperature data is then used to identify emerging hot spots and clusters of infection where testing should be focused.
  • Taiwan: High-performance infrared thermal cameras set up in airports are used to capture thermal images of people in real time to rapidly detect feverish individuals.
  • UK: Public Health England (PHE) uses syndromic surveillance—anonymized real-time health data collected from a wide range of sources, such as GPs, hospitals or even Google searches—to track the spread of the virus.
  • USA:
    • Digital thermometer maker Kinsa uses the data of its over one million devices on the market to collect real-time insights and map clusters of individuals with fevers.
    • A national study is capturing resting heart rate with smartwatches, which could be used to identify COVID-19 emerging outbreaks.
    • Oura’s smart ring measures and logs data ranging from sleep and body temperature to heart rate and respiratory function, which can assist in early COVID-19 detection. Notably, the NBA has purchased more than 1,000 Oura rings as its season restarts in Florida.

Quarantine Enforcement

Mandatory quarantine for infected or high-risk individuals has been a crucial component of many jurisdictions’ fight against the spread of COVID-19. To enforce quarantine restrictions, several governments have turned to technology to monitor individuals who are required to quarantine. This includes the use of smartphone applications and wearables.

  • Australia: In new legislation, individuals breaching quarantine will be forced to wear tracking devices with fines levied for further instances of breaking the restrictions.
    • Western Australia: Under the state’s COVID-19 response act, the police acquired 200 GPS-enabled ankle bracelets. Individuals who fail to comply with quarantine orders can be equipped with one of the bracelets.
  • Hong Kong: people in self-isolation are required to wear a wristband linked through cloud technology to a database that alerts authorities if quarantine is breached.
  • Iceland: The government has launched a mobile phone solution to monitor individuals with COVID-19 and ensure that they remain in self-isolation.
  • Kuwait: Individuals returning home from abroad are required to wear tracking bracelets. Linked with the country’s official contact tracing app, Shlonik, the bracelets notify health officials when individuals subject to isolation orders break quarantine. Use of the new bracelet is enforced through selfie requests. Violators are subject to legal action, including forced transfer to a governmental quarantine facility.
  • South Korea: Individuals in self-isolation are instructed to download a mobile phone application that alerts authorities if they leave their place of isolation.
  • Taiwan: Electronic monitoring of home-quarantined individuals is facilitated through government-issued mobile phones tracked by GPS in the event of a breach in quarantine. This so-called digital fence triggers messages to the individual and levies fines.
  • USA: Courts in Kentucky and West Virginia have mandated electronic ankle shackles for individuals who refused to submit to quarantine procedures after testing positive for COVID-19.

For media enquiries, please contact Lianne George, Director of Strategic Communications at the Brookfield Institute for Innovation + Entrepreneurship.